15 August 2008 @ 10:15 am
book review - twilight  
So, on a dare, I decided I'd try to read Twilight by Stephanie Meyer. I went into it expected it to be awful, and anticipating that I'd have to struggle my way through it just to get to the end.

I wasn't too far off, although it really wasn't that terrible of a read. It's easy and quick, and if it weren't for the fact that the characters are incredibly two-dimensional and really boring and have absolutely no character growth throughout the entire thing, I'd actually be a nice, easy read for when you're in the mood for that sort of thing. The characters are what ruined the whole thing for me. Edward and Bella don't seem to change in the slightest throughout the whole book - well, they fall in love, but if you ask me, that seems to set them back a few paces in terms of positive character development. The fact that Edward takes the role of domineering man in the relationship, in a situation where it's always "you have to do what I say because it's best for you," really, really squicks me. It just doesn't sit well. He seems controlling and possessive and she's too despondent on him. There's only once in the whole book where she goes against his desires for something she decides all on her own, and that's something she decides to protect him.

The best part of the book, I will have to admit, are the Cullens (minus Edward). His family is pretty awesome, and I always love a good vampire story. Actually, the book would probably be good if Bella and Edward weren't in it and the whole thing was just about the Cullen family and the other vampire families they meet (and probably the werewolves, too). As long as Meyer, you know, figured out how to develop interesting, deep, three-dimensional characters. Which I have no hope for.

tl;dr: If Stephanie Meyer can write five books and get it published and be "the greatest thing since Harry Potter," then so can I, dammit.
 
 
Current Mood: calmcalm
 
 
( 5 comments — Leave a comment )
Nikki: (Elen) Camelot[info]shanaqui on August 15th, 2008 02:37 pm (UTC)
The Twilight hype + the Harry Potter hype = I must write vampire wizard novels!
Erin Bow[info]erinbow on August 15th, 2008 05:22 pm (UTC)
Oh, thank goodness.... I thought I was the only one.
Ruby[info]drunkardsprayer on August 21st, 2008 02:59 pm (UTC)
xD It really is a terrible book, isn't it? I just can't believe they've become so incredibly popular. It honestly makes me concerned for young women, if this is their new idea of romance.

Late response is laaaate. ;;
Erin Bow[info]erinbow on August 22nd, 2008 05:29 am (UTC)
Well, I've only read the first one, but yeah, it's terrible. There are plenty of things that make the writer in me cringe -- like, say, Meyer's inability to distinguish between a telling detail and just another bit of clutter. But, you know, I could live with that. JK Rowling's CAPS LOCK OF RAGE didn't keep me from thinking Potter was spiffy.

What bugs me is the way it reads like a metaphor for an abusive relationship. He treats her terribly -- but it's just because he's so attracted to her. And anyway it's her fault because she smells good. And she should do everything he says because he is older and stronger and knows better. He scares her for fun, or for her own edification. He sneaks into her house at night.

And she just gives up all her choices. She's happy to let him decide whether or not to kill her, for heaven's sake. (Oh, excuse me, to decide whether or not he's strong enough to resist her tantalizing smell.) Substitute raping her for killing her and you've got a textbook abusive relationship.

Girls, if your fella starts treating you like this, get the hell out.
Ruby[info]drunkardsprayer on August 24th, 2008 02:25 am (UTC)
I know. It worries me about what younger girls are going to think about relationships. If people are going to start basing their idea of a romantic relationship after this book, I am seriously concerned about this.

He removed the engine from her truck to prevent her from leaving, for whatever reason, for Christ's sake. That's seriously not right. This book does not sit well with me - it has so many of my squicks it's not even funny. He watches her sleep. He brings oil to her room so he can fix her squeaky window so he can better slip into her room at night. He wants to check her book and CD collections to see what sorts of things she likes. It's creepy. Ugh.

Exactly. Sheesh.
( 5 comments — Leave a comment )